Case Law

Case Law

The decisions that actually shape a father’s case in Canada

Most family cases are not won or lost on a case somebody found online. They are decided on the wording of the statute and on the evidence in front of the judge. Case law matters at the edges, where the statute is silent or where a phrase like “best interests of the child” has to be given a working meaning.

Two things are worth knowing before you read any decision. Judges are bound by the Supreme Court of Canada and by the Court of Appeal in their own province. A decision from a different province is persuasive at best, and a trial decision from anywhere is only an example. And quoting a case you have read a summary of, without reading it, is one of the fastest ways to lose a judge’s confidence. If you name a case, be ready to say what happened in it and why your facts are like it.

Below are the decisions that come up most often in a separated father’s case in Canada. Each one links to the official judgment on the Supreme Court of Canada’s own site, which is free to read.

Shared parenting and the 40 percent line

Contino v. Leonelli-Contino, 2005 SCC 63 (read the judgment, Supreme Court of Canada)

This is the case behind the most common misunderstanding we hear. Section 9 of the Federal Child Support Guidelines reads: “If each spouse exercises not less than 40% of parenting time with a child over the course of a year, the amount of the child support order must be determined by taking into account” three things, the table amounts for each spouse, the increased costs of the shared arrangement, and the conditions, means, needs and other circumstances of each spouse and child. Reaching that line does not switch support off, and it does not automatically halve it. The Court held that once the 40 percent threshold is met, the amount is set using the three factors in section 9, with “emphasis on flexibility and fairness to ensure that the economic reality and particular circumstances of each family are properly accounted for”.

The Court specifically cautioned “against a rigid application of the set-off”, the arithmetic where you subtract one parent’s table amount from the other’s. A set-off is a starting point, not the answer. Read it before you assume that getting to 40 percent solves your money problem, and read our plain-language guide to how child support really works in BC alongside it.

One detail to know if you are reading the case against the current rule. Contino was decided in 2005, when section 9 spoke of access and physical custody. The section was reworded in 2020, by SOR/2020-247, to use parenting time, in step with the 2021 changes to the Divorce Act. The 40 percent line and the three factors did not change, so the case still governs how the section is applied.

Being asked for support going backwards

D.B.S. v. S.R.G., 2006 SCC 37 (read the judgment, Supreme Court of Canada)

The framework for a retroactive increase. As a general rule an award runs back to the date of “effective notice” by the other parent, and no more than three years. The sentence that catches fathers out is this one: “Effective notice does not require the recipient parent to take legal action; all that is required is that the topic be broached.”

So the clock can start with a text message. Once it has, in the Court’s words, “the payor parent can no longer assume that the status quo is fair”. Where a payor has engaged in blameworthy conduct, such as hiding a raise, the start date moves back further still, to when the circumstances actually changed.

When your income drops

Colucci v. Colucci, 2021 SCC 24 (read the judgment, Supreme Court of Canada)

The mirror image, and the one to read if your earnings have fallen. The father in this case owed roughly $170,000 in arrears. The Court set out how a payor asks for a decrease and for arrears to be rescinded, and the practical lesson is in what it requires of you.

A presumption in favour of decreasing support runs back to the date you gave “effective notice”, up to three years before you formally apply. But notice here means more than complaining. It “requires clear communication of the change in circumstances accompanied by the disclosure of any available documentation necessary to substantiate the change”. The Court put the principle plainly: “Disclosure is the linchpin on which fair support depends.”

In practice that means the day your income changes, you tell her in writing, you attach the proof, and you apply to change the order. Quietly paying less is the one route that leaves you owing all of it later. If you are already behind, our guide to what the BC Family Maintenance Agency can do, and what you can do about it covers the enforcement side.

Support after the children are grown

Michel v. Graydon, 2020 SCC 24 (read the judgment, Supreme Court of Canada)

A British Columbia case, and one nobody expects. The Court held that section 152 of BC’s Family Law Act “authorizes a court to retroactively vary a child support order, irrespective of whether the beneficiary is a ‘child’ at the time of the application, and irrespective of whether the order has expired”.

Read that twice if support has been sitting unresolved for years. A claim about underpaid support can be brought after the order has run out and after your child is an adult. It runs both ways: it is also the door that stays open for a father who overpaid on an income he no longer had.

Changing an order you already have

Gordon v. Goertz, [1996] 2 S.C.R. 27 (read the judgment, Supreme Court of Canada)

Thirty years old and still the threshold question every variation application has to get past. Before a judge will look again at parenting arrangements, the parent asking has to show a material change in circumstances: a change in the condition, means, needs or circumstances of the child or in the ability of the parents to meet the child’s needs, which materially affects the child, and which was not foreseen or could not reasonably have been contemplated when the original order was made.

The blunt version: being unhappy with the order is not a ground, and neither is an argument you wish you had made the first time. The Court said an application to vary cannot serve as an appeal. Our step-by-step on how to change a family court order in BC walks through what meeting that threshold looks like in practice.

When she wants to move away with the children

Barendregt v. Grebliunas, 2022 SCC 22 (read the judgment, Supreme Court of Canada)

The current leading relocation decision, from British Columbia, where the mother was allowed to move with the children about ten hours from the father. Three things in it matter to a father facing the same thing.

The relocation analysis still follows the framework from Gordon v. Goertz “as refined over the past two decades”. Family violence is not a side issue: courts “must consider family violence and its impact on the ability and willingness of any person who engaged in the family violence to care for and meet the needs of the child”. And judges are not to consider a parent’s testimony about whether they would move without the child, so the threat, in either direction, is not evidence.

The third point is about appeals, and it is the one that costs money. The trial judge’s findings and the weight he gave them “warranted deference on appeal”, and the Court of Appeal “was wrong to intervene”. Appeals are not a second trial. Your case is won or lost at the hearing where the evidence goes in. Since 1 March 2021 the Divorce Act also sets its own relocation notice rules, which we cover on our legal process page, and the BC picture is in our guide to relocation in BC.

If you were never married

Kerr v. Baranow, 2011 SCC 10 (read the judgment, Supreme Court of Canada)

Property between common law partners, decided on unjust enrichment rather than on the rules that apply to married couples. The case introduced the “joint family venture” idea, that where two people worked together for a common purpose, one partner’s contribution can be recognised as a share in what was built rather than as a bill for hours worked.

How much this matters depends on where you live, because provinces treat unmarried couples differently. In British Columbia, section 3 of the Family Law Act makes you a spouse if you lived with your partner in a marriage-like relationship “for a continuous period of at least 2 years”, and a spouse gets the property rules in Part 5.

There is a trap in that section worth reading carefully. Having a child together also makes you a spouse for most of the Act, but the section says that branch does not apply in Part 5, Property Division, or Part 6, Pension Division. So an unmarried father who has a child with his partner but lived with her for less than two years is a spouse for support purposes and not for dividing property. That is the situation Kerr was written for.

How to look a case up properly

The full text of almost every Canadian decision is free at the Canadian Legal Information Institute (CanLII). Supreme Court decisions are also on the Court’s own site at Judgments of the Supreme Court of Canada. Both are free and neither requires an account.

Three habits worth having. Search by the citation, the “2021 SCC 24” part, rather than by the name, because names repeat. On CanLII, check how later courts have treated the decision before you rely on it, since a case can be distinguished or overtaken. And read the paragraphs you intend to use, not the summary, because the summary is not what the judge is bound by.

Then use it carefully. Judges decide family cases on the statutory factors and on evidence. A case helps you when it explains what a factor means. It does not help you as a substitute for showing what has actually happened with your children.

Where to get help with this

What this page does not do

This is not legal advice and it is not a complete list. It covers decisions of the Supreme Court of Canada, which bind every court in the country. Your province’s Court of Appeal will also have decisions that bind the judge hearing your case, and those are the ones a local lawyer or duty counsel will know.

Every case above was read on the Supreme Court of Canada’s own site, and every quoted phrase is taken from the judgment itself. Checked 11 August 2026.

Latest Legal News

NotABadDad provides general legal information and support resources for fathers. We are not a law firm and we do not provide legal advice. Using this site does not create a lawyer-client relationship. For advice about your specific situation, consult a licensed lawyer.

In crisis? Call or text 988 (Canada, available 24/7).